Baker's Dozen: a J Dilla drum machine

A J Dilla drum machine.

Loading the room

Best with sound on

RHYTHM PRODUCTION CENTER
TIMING:DILLA BPM:88
TIMING
STRAIGHT SWING DILLA
TEMPO
TRACK
TRANSPORT
STEPS · KICK

Liner notes

BAKER'S DOZEN

A J Dilla drum machine. It lets you hear, see and change what he did to rhythm.

What this is

One beat, played three ways: straight, swung, and Dilla. Every drum hit is drawn on the machine's screen exactly as far off the beat as it sounds, with the distance written in milliseconds. Turn the wheel to move between the three feels, then drag any hit early or late and listen to the whole beat lean.

It's a tribute and an explanation at once. You can read about Dilla's timing in a book, but it only makes sense when you move a snare yourself and feel what 20 milliseconds does.

Who J Dilla was

James Dewitt Yancey, known as Jay Dee and later J Dilla, was a producer from Detroit. He was born on 7 February 1974 and died on 10 February 2006, aged 32.

He came up with his group Slum Village and went on to make beats for The Pharcyde (Runnin'), De La Soul (Stakes Is High), A Tribe Called Quest, Common (The Light) and Erykah Badu (Didn't Cha Know). He was part of the Soulquarians, the loose group around Questlove, D'Angelo, Common and Badu.

He built most of it on one machine, an Akai MPC3000 sampler. That machine now sits in the Smithsonian's National Museum of African American History and Culture. His last album, Donuts, came out on his 32nd birthday, three days before he died.

What "Dilla time" means

Before Dilla, popular music had two ways to feel time. Straight time divides the beat evenly: tick, tick, tick, tick. Swing divides it unevenly: long, short, long, short. A drum machine made you pick one, and its quantise button snapped every note onto that grid.

Dilla did both at once. He kept some parts straight and swung others, and he nudged single drums a hair early or late and left them there. The hi-hats might run dead even while the snare lands slightly ahead of them and the kick drags behind.

It sounds loose, even drunk. It isn't. The snare is early by the same amount every single bar. That exactness is what separates it from a drummer playing behind the beat, and it's why it was so hard to copy.

The term comes from Dan Charnas's 2022 book Dilla Time, which argues this was a third way to feel rhythm, after straight and swing. Drummers have since learned to play it by hand.

What we measured

To set the numbers on this machine, we measured where the drums fall on short previews of eleven records he produced: the snare on beats 2 and 4, against the hi-hats.

RecordYearSnare against the hats
The Pharcyde, Runnin'1995On the beat
De La Soul, Stakes Is High1996On the beat
Slum Village, Raise It Up200019 ms early
Slum Village, Keep It On200027 to 30 ms early
Slum Village, Untitled / Fantastic2000About 9 ms early, over swung hats and a late kick

Press Record on the machine to hear each of these: it sets the snare, kick and hats where we measured them.

In these records the snare sits on the beat in the mid-90s, and by Slum Village's Fantastic Vol. 2 it has moved 9 to 30 milliseconds early, in the same place every bar. That's a small sample measured from 30-second clips, so treat it as a pointer, not a law. The kick drums were too tangled with the bass to measure reliably.

The three settings

How to play it

Listen

The Dilla Time Listening Guide playlist on Spotify.

Open the playlist in Spotify

Why Baker's Dozen, and why a donut box

The box is for Donuts, his last album. A baker's dozen is thirteen: a dozen that's off by one. Being slightly off, on purpose and every time, is the whole idea.

Count the donuts on the table. There are twelve. The drum machine took their box, which makes it the thirteenth.

Credits and reading

An unofficial tribute. Not affiliated with or endorsed by J Dilla's estate.