Writing · Side project

Baker's Dozen: A J Dilla drum machine, in a donut box

Under four hours, about 65 messages, one new name and a donut that arrived standing on its edge. What worked, what I got wrong, and how I prompted.

On Slum Village's Raise It Up, J Dilla's snare lands 19 milliseconds before the beat, in the same place every bar. I wanted a drum machine where you could grab that snare and move it yourself. So I asked Claude to build one. Then I asked it to put the machine in a donut box.

A dark room with one spotlight on a wooden table. A pink donut box with a clear lid sits on the table with a drum machine inside it, and twelve iced donuts lie around the box.
The room. The drum machine has taken the box, so the donuts are on the table.

01The idea

This is another side project built by describing it. Sample Explorer was a tool, the Listening Room was a place, and ALL CAPS was a room for MF DOOM.

DOOM hid things, so his tribute was a room full of secrets. James Yancey, J Dilla, did something to time. On his MPC3000 he kept some parts straight, swung others, and nudged single drums a hair early or late and left them there. It sounds loose, but each hit lands in the same place every bar. Dan Charnas's book Dilla Time calls it a third way to feel rhythm, after straight and swing.

You can read that sentence and not hear a thing, so the tribute had to be something you play.

Baker's Dozen is a drum machine in your browser. It plays one beat three ways: straight, swing and Dilla. Every hit is drawn on the screen as far off the beat as it sounds, with the distance in milliseconds, and you can drag any of them.

02The brief

My first message pointed at the last three projects and asked for ideas:

Look at my sample project, my listening room and most recently ALL CAPS projects and help me to plan a new project, this time for J DILLA. Research into the artist and help me generate some ideas based on what you find

Claude read the three write-ups, researched him and came back with five ideas. One was another walkable room. One was his album Donuts as a ring you spin. The one it recommended was a drum machine where you drag the beat, because it was the only idea that put his timing in your hands. My reply was two words:

Dilla Time

That was the working name. It lasted nearly three hours.

03Check first

Same rule as Sample Explorer: before designing anything, find out whether the thing you need exists. Here there were two things. Can a browser play a drum hit on time to the millisecond? And does anyone publish where Dilla's hits fall?

The first answer was yes. Claude recorded the browser's own output and checked where 176 clicks landed. All 176 were within a fiftieth of a millisecond. It also froze the page on purpose to see what broke, and it broke: hits arrived up to 76 ms late. Booking each hit a quarter of a second ahead fixed it.

The second answer was no. The good writing on his timing shows it in pictures, without numbers. So I said:

Yes, measure them

Claude wrote a tool that finds each kick, snare and hi-hat in a short preview and stacks every bar on top of the others. Before pointing it at a record it tested it on a beat it had made, with the snare 18 ms early. The tool said 18.4.

RecordYearSnare, against the hi-hats
The Pharcyde, Runnin'1995On the beat
De La Soul, Stakes Is High1996On the beat
Slum Village, Raise It Up200019 ms early
Slum Village, Keep It On200027 to 30 ms early
Slum Village, Untitled / Fantastic2000About 9 ms early, over swung hats and a late kick

In these records the snare sits on the beat in the mid-90s and has moved early by 2000. It's a small sample from 30-second clips, so I wouldn't claim more than that. But it gave the machine real numbers, and those numbers later became a button that sets the machine to each record.

04What got built

3h 37mfirst message to live on my site
~65messages from me, in one sitting
12donuts on the table. The machine is the thirteenth
0lines of code I typed

What happens when you open it:

A black screen with the words Baker's Dozen, a line reading A J Dilla drum machine, and an ivory wall light switch.The switch
The donut box open on the table, its lid standing up and lit green from the drum machine's screen inside.The box
The drum machine seen from above: a green screen with five rows of drum hits, a dial, track keys and sixteen pads.The machine
Turn on the light, open the box, play.

05The look: mine first, then his

The first playable version was dressed like my own website: a serif headline, hairlines, one green accent. I'd played with it for a few minutes before I said so:

This is awesome but I really want to make this something that is Dilla styled and themed, it just follows my standard design of my own site

Claude stopped and offered three worlds: the machine he worked on, a 1950s donut shop, or a home-dubbed beat tape. I picked the machine: a warm grey chassis, a green screen in pixel type, rubber pads and a dial, with no brand names on it.

The first version: a pale page with a serif title, a slider and a grid of dots.My site's style
The second version: a grey drum machine with a green screen, a dial and pads.His machine
The same instrument, an hour apart.

A little later I wanted the donut shop as well:

Do you think we can make it so that the drum machine sits inside a pink donut box, closed, on a desk in the middle of a room which is nothing but the room with a spotlight that is over the top of the drum machine. It is well rendered as a 3d model, and when clicking it the donut box, the lid opens, the camera zooms and pans to the drum machine from a birds eye view and it becomes playable

Claude built the opening from that message by measuring the real page: every pad, key and dial is rebuilt in 3D in the same spot, so when the camera lands overhead the real machine can fade in on top of the model.

The room then took a dozen short messages. The desk was wrong and there were no donuts:

The desk is a bit weird, it's not the type of desk I'd expect to see this on... but let's add donuts on the table around the box, as if they drum machine has taken over the box and the donuts are outside of it

An earlier version of the room: the pink box on a grey steel office desk with drawers, and no donuts.
The steel office desk. A fine desk, for an accountant.

06The name

Nearly three hours in, with an About page written, Claude pointed out something I hadn't checked. Dilla Time is the title of Dan Charnas's book, and the playlist I'd embedded belongs to an account of the same name. Mine would look like an official companion.

Suggest alternatives

try again for names,

Baker's Dozen is better, but with a simple subline

A baker's dozen is thirteen: a dozen that's off by one. Being slightly off, on purpose and every time, is what the machine is about. Claude added three donuts to make twelve on the table. The machine in their box is the thirteenth.

07How it works

The short version. Skip it if you came for the prompting.

08How I prompted

Like a design crit, again. These are my real messages, typos included.

Name the feeling, then the cause

the animation to open the box to the actual machine is a tiny bit jarring, how do we fix that

"Jarring" got three fixes: a stutter at the moment of landing, a brightness jump and a small shift in the pads. It was better and still wrong. I looked again and could say why:

the colours of the machine in the box and the machine head on are what make it jarring, colour match exactly

That's when the unlit copy went in. My next message was "much much better".

Turn a limit into the design

I'd asked for the lamp to flicker on with a click and a buzz. Claude said it couldn't: no sound before the first tap. So I asked a question:

Do we need a loader, then when clicking the CTA for the loader, it can trigger the sound for the light switch click and buzz

The loading screen became a light switch. It covers the wait, it's the tap the browser needs, and it's the first thing you'd do in a dark room anyway.

Keep saying it isn't good enough

donut ice on the donuts need major improvement, it's blocky

still can be. alot bette

Claude rebuilt the icing twice and then told me where the ceiling was: these were shapes made in code, and a scan of a real donut would beat them. It couldn't download one without an account. I could.

Use a scanned one

I found one on Sketchfab and dropped the file in. It's the lesson from ALL CAPS again: find, don't build.

Use your own ears

Claude can't hear. It said so every time it touched a sound, and asked me to listen. When I did:

i've listened, it sounds ok but what would you do to improve it?

It gave me five things, starting with the big one: the drums were made from tones and noise, and his sound is drums lifted off records. I said "do them all". Six minutes later there were recorded drums, a Wurlitzer, a bass line you can drag, and keys that duck under each kick.

sounds so much better now

Ask what's left, with a condition

ok, what's left, to truly improve by simplifying or adding, only when making a true impact

The list had five things to do and four to cut. The best one replaced three planned sections with a single button, the one that sets the machine to a record. Another was a problem I'd never have found: the machine didn't fit on a laptop screen, and it had only looked fine because the window we were both using was unusually tall.

Kill ideas quickly

does replacing the O in dozen work with a donu?

Claude mocked it up on the first screen and told me it wouldn't do it: a round donut breaks a tall, narrow word. I looked.

no doesn't look good

That took about a minute, and nothing in the project had been touched.

09What broke

What I sawWhat was actually wrongThe fix
The box landed off to one side of the machineA label Claude gave the page while the box was closed had the same name as the style for the intro text. The whole page was being squeezed to 44 characters wideA different name
The machine changed colour as the real one took overA model lit by a lamp can't match a flat page, however the lamp is tuned. And when the unlit copy went in, invisible label layers were hiding itThe unlit copy, drawn in front, with the lit one hidden at landing
Twelve donuts standing on their edgesThe scan wasn't stored lying flatFind the direction in which the donut is thinnest, stand that up, then turn the iced side to the top
The preview of my own site refused to buildClaude's commits carried an email address that GitHub ties to a different accountI changed one setting. Claude tried to fix it itself and wasn't allowed to change who the commits were from
"Completely broken on phone, landscape"The 3D picture kept the shape the screen had before I turned the phone. And a leftover rule stretched the button into a blobThe picture re-reads the screen's size as it runs
The room with twelve donuts standing upright on their edges around the box.The scan, as delivered
A phone screenshot: the room looks squashed flat and a huge pink circle reading Open the box covers the top of the screen.On my phone
Two that only showed up when the real thing arrived: a real donut, and a real phone.

Claude had tested phone sizes all afternoon and they'd passed. It had always loaded the page already on its side. A person picks the phone up, opens the link and then turns it. My two screenshots found three bugs in a minute.

10On a phone

A drum machine is wider than it is tall, so I made a call early:

Make this a landscape only thing on phones and touch devices, portrait makes no sese

Held upright, the page says "Turn your phone sideways" and nothing else. On its side, the whole machine fits one screen in three columns.

Later I asked for an accessibility pass. It found real problems: you could tab into the hidden machine, small labels were too faint, there was no way to skip the intro. It fixed them. It also added a way past the sideways rule, because the guidelines say not to lock a screen's orientation, and it told me it had changed something I'd asked for. I took it back out:

block portrait completely, it makes no sense

That one's on me. It's written down in the project notes as my decision, with the guideline it goes against.

11What I took from it

The look belongs to the subject. My first version was a nice page about Dilla. It needed to be his machine. Ask whose world it is before the first screen.

Check first, then measure. Ten minutes of checking told me the timing would hold and that the numbers I wanted didn't exist. Measuring them took most of an hour and turned into the best feature.

Find, don't build. The table, the donut, the drums and the piano all got good the moment they were real things someone had already recorded or scanned. All free, with credit.

You are the ears, and the phone. Claude can read a page and measure a click to a fiftieth of a millisecond. It can't hear a snare or hold a phone. The two biggest jumps in quality came from me listening for ten seconds and from two screenshots.

Name the feeling, then look again. "Jarring" got three sensible fixes and stayed jarring. "The colours" got the right one.

Ask what to cut. Three planned sections became one button, a card of instructions became one line, and six planned secrets became one.

Go and turn on the light. Open the box, turn the dial to Dilla, and pull the snare early. Then count the donuts.

Open the box ↗

An unofficial tribute to James Dewitt Yancey, 1974–2006. Not affiliated with his estate. Built with Claude Code. The idea of "Dilla time" is from Dan Charnas's book Dilla Time; Ethan Hein's writing on it helped. Donut scan by Viky_3D (CC BY 4.0, via Sketchfab). Drums from Big Rusty Drums by Karoryfer Samples (CC0). Wurlitzer EP200 recorded by Greg Sullivan (CC BY 3.0). Table and floor from Poly Haven (CC0). None of J Dilla's recordings are used.